
Defendants appealed judgments from the Superior Court of Los Angeles County (California) convicting them of first degree murder and kidnapping for the purpose of robbery with the victim suffering bodily harm.
The defendant shooter contended that the shotgun admitted into evidence was obtained via an illegal search and seizure. The defendant accomplice contended that there was no evidence of the corpus delicti of the crime of kidnapping for the purpose of robbery. Both defendants contended that they did not knowingly and intelligently waive their constitutional rights to counsel and to remain silent. However, rejecting these contentions, the court affirmed the defendants' convictions. The challenged search was incident to the arrest of the defendant shooter, such that the search was constitutional if the arrest was lawful. The requisite probable cause for the arrest was established. Also, ADA lawyer Orange County the requisite corpus delicti was established. Finally, although the defendant accomplice possessed the mental age of a minor, the age of a juvenile did not rule out the possibility of an intelligent waiver of Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights. It was a matter of proof in each instance. In this case, the evidence demonstrated that the defendants had knowingly and intelligently waived their rights to counsel and to remain silent.
Defendants appealed judgments from the Superior Court of Los Angeles County (California) convicting them of first degree murder and kidnapping for the purpose of robbery with the victim suffering bodily harm.
The defendant shooter contended that the shotgun admitted into evidence was obtained via an illegal search and seizure. The defendant accomplice contended that there was no evidence of the corpus delicti of the crime of kidnapping for the purpose of robbery. Both defendants contended that they did not knowingly and intelligently waive their constitutional rights to counsel and to remain silent. However, rejecting these contentions, the court affirmed the defendants' convictions. The challenged search was incident to the arrest of the defendant shooter, such that the search was constitutional if the arrest was lawful. The requisite probable cause for the arrest was established. Also, the requisite corpus delicti was established. Finally, although the defendant accomplice possessed the mental age of a minor, the age of a juvenile did not rule out the possibility of an intelligent waiver of Fifth and Sixth Amendment rights. It was a matter of proof in each instance. In this case, the evidence demonstrated that the defendants had knowingly and intelligently waived their rights to counsel and to remain silent.
Defendants' convictions were affirmed.